Wednesday, February 3, 2010

Rasa Theory in a few lines

Rasa theory is based on the idea that you can have a transcendental experience through art.

Interestingly enough, this is the simple philosophy as to why:

Say you see Romeo and Juliet on the stage. It's a great rendition, and you have the experience that people like to say is an immersion experience. You seem to forget about the world around you, and begin to empathize with the characters. So, what is it that you are feeling?

Is it Romeo and Juliet's love for each other? No, because they don't exist.

Is it your love for Romeo? No, because he is fictional and you are not.

Is it a past experience of love that you are experiencing? No, because it perhaps does not exist now in time, or you may not have experienced it at all yet.

So then what is it? You are certainly experiencing something, even though clearly it is something that does not exist as you seem to know it. It must, in that case, be true love, unmarred by earthly bounds. Real, unadulterated, unbiased love. The universal love.

In other words, the viewer is able to transcend the human emotional feeling of love and experience truth in the form of love on a different plane altogether. And, if you apply this to religious love and devotion, the same rules apply by simply creating great religious theater. By creating devotion on stage, you can experience true devotion mentally.

Granted rasa has strict rules you must follow to experience this, but this is the basic idea.

The function of art, according to me.

I find art fascinating because it allows for contrary forces to operate at the same time. It is one of the few subjects in the world that can function at opposite ends of different spectrums simultaneously.

At the most general level it affects both the individual and the collective. Individually, it allows the viewer to remove him/herself from emotions while also experiencing them, creating an almost cathartic effect similar to what Aristotle speaks of when he analyzes Greek tragedy. At the same time, it affords the viewer the transcendental experience that rasa theoreticians like to claim is its purpose.

An individual also does not need knowledge of a genre's particular vocabulary to appreciate art, making it a universal subject that crosses and breaks boundaries. Yet, it remains regional: a person armed with that kind of knowledge is at an advantage nonetheless, and art sometimes is not wholly functional for the spectator without it.

While the individual has the capacity to be transformed by art, it can change the face of a society as a whole is as well. Indian classical dance, in the face of extinction fifty years ago, intertwined itself with the well being of India as a nation state and became an integral part of the independence movement, both dictating and reflecting the values people hold today.

Art is also not transformative in nature; simply reflecting the world around it in a poignant manner. For instance, Indian dance recently saw a huge spurt of productions about the power of the female. An analysis of this revealed a backlash to governmental ideals of women during the Independence movement - so art has shown a revealing look into the psyche of women post-revolution. Again, at the other end of the spectrum, it can also be representative of an artist's notions of the world around it, like Picasso.

So, art is full of simultaneous dichotomies - it both transforms and quietly reflects, it is individual and societal, it is real and transcendental, it is cathartic and can rile the soul. Politics in art has its place, just as sticking to tradition and not creating new work does, and those who claim anything one way or the other seem to have no idea that art has no rules. Society likes to give it rules and restrictions to make it easier to comprehend, to claim that we know what the supreme meaning of art is, but at the end of the day art has a vast myriad of functions and we can only point out what these are and perhaps analyze how to achieve them as such.

Thursday, January 28, 2010

Alistair MacCaulay's obsession with Indian classical dance

As long as you dress up and bang your feet around a little bit this New York Times critic will be taken away by the label "Indian Classical Dance".

That's all.

Dance on Camera Festival: Nrityagram

I don' t know why people are so afraid to say "I don't know, maybe someone in the audience does..."

I encountered this particularly frustrating panel (Mark Morris and the director of a movie on Nrityagram named Nan) who repeatedly answered questions in a misleading fashion. There's no better way to perpetuate ignorance and unfounded lies than to put someone on stage who you *think* knows what they are talking and have them unequivocally and matter of factly spew BS. And it happens so often in Indian classical dance.

The worst was there were several knowledgeable artists in the audience who kept trying to answer the questions and we were shushed or ignored! "Traditionalists" of Indian dance were vilified, and a very one-sided picture of Indian artists and the dance scene was painted.

So if you don't know, say so, and open it up to those who do!

Sigh. How sad.

Sunday, December 13, 2009

The visual pleasures in music

Whenever I listen to music, I also watch it. I take particular pleasure in watching hands fly over mridangams, or fingers run through the frets of an instrument at amazing speeds.

Here is a great video of U. Shrinivas, a fantastic mandolin player, that exemplifies what I'm saying.

Wednesday, December 9, 2009

A practical theory on why dance/theater became so stylized

Because of large audiences! It allows meanings to be clear (assuming you know what the meanings of certain gestures are to begin with) and, for those packed theaters, allows those that are in the back to know exactly what's going on even if they can't see the expression on someone's face or make out what they are saying exactly! (Think: Shakespearean theater).

Of course, this is before mics and the invention of the proscenium theater and film and small intimate spaces. Is stylization so necessary now? Does it take away or add to a performance?

Rasa theory would certainly state that it's necessary, for more than the practical reasons. Rasa theory demands that one not delve too fully into a character or emote naturally because then you break down that fourth wall - the one where the audience and performers know that it is a play that is going on, an important aid in achieving a "spiritual high" when experiencing art.

However, currently, it is realistic acting that everyone is trying to achieve. Noh theater, bharatanatyam dancers, Shakespeare, Bollywood, etc: things that have been stylized for years and years are now making its way into the world of "realistic" acting. I wonder though that this is little more than the West's hegemony over the East. When stylization is scoffed upon and misunderstood by Western audiences as poor acting or performing, (I myself am guilty of this!) and Easterners are concerned with "being as good as the West", there seems little other reason for it.